Slightly Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

These slightly organic stuffed mushrooms are perfect for your next football tailgating party. They are delicious and great served as an appetizer. Or, fix them as a side for your next meal! I love the bacon topped filling. They are sure to be a crowd-pleaser!

Prep: 20 minutes | Cook: 25 minutes | Total: 45 minutes | Servings: 2

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms


  • 12 organic button mushrooms
  • 4 oz Philadelphia Original Cream Cheese, softened
  • 3 strips bacon, finely chopped
  • 1 small shallot, peeled and finely chopped
  • 2 organic garlic cloves, peeled and minced
  • 2 tablespoons organic green onions, chopped
  • 1 oz Frigo Crumbled Blue Cheese
  • (1 tablespoon red wine – optional)
  • salt and pepper


Preheat oven to 400 F.

Rinse each mushroom and dry with paper towels. Gently break off stems and finely chop.

Covered with paper towel in microwave, cook 3 strips bacon (the 3rd is for you to eat while you cook) until lightly brown and crisp. Remove from microwave and set aside.

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

In pan, add shallots and garlic and sauté until lightly browned. Add chopped mushroom stems and continue to cook, stirring regularly, for about 4 to 5 minutes. Season with salt and pepper to taste.

Organic Stuffed MushroomsOptional – add in red wine and continue to cook, stirring regularly, until mushrooms are tender and liquid is evaporated. Remove from pan and allow to cool.

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

In a mixing bowl, combine cream cheese and blue cheese. Fold in mushroom blend, crisp bacon bits and green onions in pan.

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

Arrange mushroom caps gills down on a baking sheet and lightly smear with olive oil. Bake in a 400 F oven for about 4 to 5 minutes or until mushrooms start to leak.

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

Turn mushroom caps to cavity side up and using a small spoon, fill with cheese mixture.

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

Return to oven and bake at 400 F for another 5 to 6 minutes or until stuffing is heated through and tops are golden brown.

Organic Stuffed MushroomsWhat’s your favorite tailgating recipe? Comment below and share with us!

Organic Stuffed Mushrooms

Melanie Kampman

Melanie Kampman is a web designer, developer and owner of Giveaway Bandit and Farm News for Kids. She lives in Northwest Missouri on a large family farm with her husband and eight year old son, the Giveaway Bandit. They raise cattle with a variety of pets including horses, chickens, ducks, and a slew of cats. By Melanie Kampman If you are interested in writing a sponsored post on Giveaway Bandit please email me at melanie (at) giveawaybandit (dot) com.

  • denise226

    great recipe thanks so much for sharing it

  • Erica Weaver

    omg i am drooling these look so good i love stuffed mushrooms

  • Rachel Beltz

    “Slightly” organic. I love that heh! I am a mushroom lover so these are so happening. My stomach is growling at just the sight of these babies!!

  • slehan

    I like the flavors in this stuffing. Can I have some now?
    slehan at juno dot com

  • Sharon Mink

    Look delicious!

  • WHOA! Those look wonderful! Also, I’m lovin’ the name you came up with for the recipe… “SLIGHTLY organic stuffed mushrooms.” HA!

  • qq

    really great!

  • donna porter

    These look delicious…I will be making them for my family!

  • Amanda Alvarado

    I’m not a fan of blue cheese so I’d probably mix it with mozzarella instead! Otherwise these look so yummy!!!

  • Seyma Shabbir

    I love mushrooms and also not a fan of blue cheese but when the flavors come together it works well. I will have to try this!! Thanks for sharing!

  • Cindy S.

    Oooh! These sound and look amazing. Pinning now for future reference. Yum, yum.

  • Rajeeva Jayaratne

    i love mushrooms and this looks yummy.

  • Christina Sparks

    These look really yummy!

  • Jeanna johnson

    These look delicious & a perfect snack for game day!

  • Becky Richardson

    OMG! Am saving this for football season. Thanks for sharing.

  • Sandy Klocinski

    WOW! These sound great. Thanks for sharing

  • Karen Giasson

    I love this recipe!!! I make stuffed mushrooms all the time, but haven’t tried this recipe yet. But, I will now.

  • Melissa S

    Wow, these sound really amazing. My husband and would love these for dinner. I am pinning to add what I need to my grocery list. Thank you for the recipe.

  • Christina G.

    The pictures look delicious. I’d love to try this recipe. Thanks for sharing!

  • April monty

    My guy would love these mushrooms! I hardly ever make things like this for him.

  • Enzo Stolzenburg

    those look delicious! I´ll definitely make those for my girlfriend soon

  • Holly Thomas

    These look so good, I have to try them!

  • Leslie Crosbie

    Sounds delicious but what the heck does slightly organic mean? Lol

  • Francine Anchondo

    My husband would love these

  • Stephanie Larison

    Wow these look amazing, I need to try!

  • Natalie

    These look delicious except for the cream cheese. What could I substitute?

  • Richard Hicks

    I bet these would not last very long!

  • 1alwaysnyc1

    These look so yummy – cream cheese, bacon, blue cheese (maybe?). Appys for next party!

  • inkchick

    These look tasty and fun. Definitely a winner for a casual gathering.

  • ClickClick

    I have been looking for a good stuffed mushroom recipe. This one looks really good.

  • Amanda Patterson

    I loved stuffed mushrooms and these look great! Thanks for the recipe 🙂

  • cynthiac

    I love to stuff mushrooms as appetizers or snacks. They make a perfect finger food and everyone seems to enjoy them. Yours look delicious!

  • Darla Peduzzi

    These sound so good! I love stuffed mushrooms but have never made them. I think I could do this recipe. Thanks for sharing!

  • Jill Myrick

    These look so delicious ! My family and I love mushrooms in every shape for and fashion but especially stuffed mushrooms. We will definitely be trying this recipe at home.


  • Ariska

    look so youmi

  • Ronald Gagnon

    What a wonderful appetizer and ready in 45 minutes..could be a life saver

  • Dotty J Boucher

    I am not a big fan of mushrooms, but everyone else is in the family, I know hubby would love this recipe you have here,

  • Nancy Burgess

    I love mushrooms I’m going to try this recipe.

  • belinda bell

    I love stuffed mushrooms. This recipe sounds yummy

  • amycrocker76

    Thanks for the great recipe! Now I can make these at home. I remember the first time I tried stuffed mushrooms in line at a restaurant buffet.

  • Jeanna Schirm Massman

    My grandson loves mushrooms so this might be a a great treat for him.

  • Nena Sinclair

    Omg this sounds like heaven! I must make them very soon! Thanks for sharing your recipe!

  • hannah

    finally a healthy snack i can bring to football games

  • April monty

    This is a great snack not too big, but still filling.

  • Amber Terry

    These look delicious. I love mushrooms, but I don’t eat them that often, mostly because I don’t make too many dishes that involve them. This sounds like something I would definitely make as often as possible now that I’ve seen the recipe 🙂 Thanks for sharing!!

  • Carolyn Cheek- Massey

    We love stuffed mushrooms organic or not. This recipe looks so yummy and will disappear around this house.

  • clojo9372

    This is amazing!! <3 I love mushrooms and in my opinion bacon makes everything awesome! This is definitely a recipe I would like to try! 🙂

  • April monty

    My guy would make short work of these lol he loved mushrooms he puts them in everything

  • Lisa Coomer Queen

    Oh gosh! These looks so yummy! My husband would love these. Thank you for the recipe.

  • Elena

    these look delicious! I am going to try this recipe

  • Cheryl Everitt

    Recipe is easy peasy and delicious! Thank you.

  • Karen Glatt

    I want to make these mushrooms. They look so delicious. Thanks for sharing a wonderful recipe.

  • Pops

    They look so delicious and i love mushrooms so this recipe has to be great

  • debbiewelchert

    This look and sound so delicious. I know this is something my whole family will enjoy.

  • Miranda Messick

    Mmmmm just looking at this is making me hungry. I will have to give it a try! Oh and I love the mustache btw.

  • Ronald Gagnon

    Fantastic recipe..but I think I will use 36 mushrooms and 8 strips of use it as my entre..thank you

  • Jerry Marquardt

    The Slightly Organic Stuffed Mushrooms recipe looks astounding. I cannot
    wait to taste your special recipe. I thank you so much for the
    directions on this delicious treat.

Giveaway Bandit is your destination to win prizes in online giveaways, free stuff and sweepstakes. We are a lifestyle blog focusing on product video reviews, travel, giveaways, home, garden, recipes, diy and entertainment.

Submit your listing to our giveaway directory - contests, sweepstakes or giveaways! Plus, we share them with our fans on social media!